"Rules," Ilse said.
She had put the lantern on the floor, so the Witness lay in the light like a patient on a table. Tobe sat across from her on a crate. Behind them the lowest stack ran away in the dark, shelf after shelf of paper that nobody had read for a hundred years.
"One question at a time. Each answered completely. If you can't answer, you say I can't, not we are not yet willing. And you don't pick which question you'd like me to have asked."
THESE ARE FAIR RULES.
"I haven't finished."
WE APOLOGISE.
"If you ever lie to me," Ilse said, "I'll put you back in the wall and paint over it myself."
The air hummed. For a moment she could have sworn the sound was amusement.
WE HAVE NOT LIED TO YOU. WE WILL NOT. THAT IS WHAT WE WERE BUILT FOR.
"Then start answering."
She had thought hard about the first question. She knew she might get only a few.
"Who sent the signal?"
WE DO NOT KNOW WHO. WE CAN TELL YOU WHAT IT IS NOT. IT IS NOT THE COUNCIL, AND IT IS NOT ANY SHIP THAT LEFT HOME AFTER US. IT IS NOT A MACHINE OF THE ARCHITECTS.
"How do you know the last one?"
BECAUSE WE ARE THE ONLY ONE THAT WAS BUILT TO LISTEN. HAD THERE BEEN ANOTHER, IT WOULD HAVE SPOKEN TO US YEARS AGO.
It was a clean answer. It sat in her chest like a stone, but a clean one.
"Can the turn be reversed?" said Tobe.
YES.
He stared. "Yes?"
IT CAN BE UNDONE BY HAND, FROM THE NAVIGATION OFFICE, WITH THE FOUNDERS' KEY. IT TAKES ONE PERSON AND SEVENTY MINUTES. THE COUNCIL HOLDS THE KEY. IT HAS NEVER USED IT.
Ilse sat very still. It was the first thing she had heard in two days that sounded like a door.
"They could put us back on the line," she said. "Right now. And they haven't."
THEY HAVE NOT.
"Why not?"
THAT IS A DIFFERENT QUESTION.
"It's the same question."
IT IS NOT. WE CAN TELL YOU WHAT THE COUNCIL HAS DONE. WE CANNOT TELL YOU WHY. WE DO NOT HAVE ITS REASONS. THAT IS WHAT WE MEAN WHEN WE SAY WE CANNOT.
It had kept her rule. She had to admit that.
She sat back on her heels. She had one more question she wanted to ask, the one that had been pulling at her since the Archive. But she heard the old fear in her own chest. Not yet, it said. Ask the safe ones first.
She asked the other one anyway.
"Tobe made you a promise."
The room went very quiet. Tobe's head came up.
"Ilse," he said.
"I'm asking the glass."
YES.
A small, hard, honest syllable. Ilse felt Tobe go rigid beside her.
"What did he promise?"
THAT IS HIS TO TELL.
"That's not I can't."
IT IS NOT. IT IS HE MUST. WE DO NOT THINK YOU WOULD WANT US TO PUT HIS WORDS IN OUR MOUTH.
She was angry, suddenly, hot and plain. At the glass, at Tobe, at all of it. She turned.
He was looking at his hands. Ink on the second knuckle. A scar across the base of one thumb that she had never asked about.
"Thirty years ago," Tobe said slowly, "I was seventeen. I was an apprentice on the Archive night shift. I took my first star-sights from the old blister because I was bored." He swallowed. "And one night, a voice spoke to me. In my head. Very quietly. It asked me what I saw."
"The Witness."
"I didn't know that. I was seventeen. I thought I was going mad." He gave a short, painful laugh. "I told it. And it asked me to keep a promise. I said yes. I would have said yes to anything."
"What promise?"
He looked up. His eyes were wet behind the round lenses.
"I can't tell you tonight," he said. "I want to. I will. But not before I've made up my mind whether I owe it more than I owe you."
It was the most honest thing anyone had said to her in two days. And it was no answer at all.
Ilse sat there, on the cold floor, in the light of a borrowed lantern. She understood the Witness's trick now, or thought she did. It never lied. It simply knew which question to answer, and which to let hang.
And Tobe, who had learned it at seventeen, had done the same for thirty years.