By morning, everyone knew.
Not the whole truth. Nobody had that. But a rumour is lighter than a fact and travels faster, and by the time Ilse came down from the Archive with her pack on her back, there were notices on every pillar in Ring Nine.
They were cheap, hand-pressed, black on grey. The same four words, over and over, at the height of a man's eyes.
THE LINE IS A LIE.
Under them, smaller: The ship is turning. The Council has known. Ask them why.
Ilse stopped in front of one. It did not say who had printed it. It did not say how they knew. It said nothing about hatches or glass or signals from outside the world, and for that she was, selfishly, grateful.
Tobe had gone grey when she told him. "Not me," he said at once. "Not my paper. I never printed a word."
"Then who?"
"Someone with a press, and a reason, and the same cards we found." He turned the notice over. The back was blank. "Someone who wants it known, and doesn't mind who gets hurt."
The argument began at the bakery.
It was small at first, the way fires are. A woman who had given away bread the day before stood at her counter with the notice pinned beside the till, and a man in a work coat said, loudly, that it was nonsense. The Council had said lamp fault. The Council did not lie.
"They lied about the cards," said the baker.
"What cards?"
"Thirty years of cards! It's on the notice!"
By noon, the whole terrace was out. By afternoon, it had a shape. Ilse watched it form, a thing she had never seen on the Lantern in her life, which was people choosing sides.
On one side were those who wanted to follow the turn. Mostly younger. Mostly angry. They said the ship was doing something, and nobody had asked it why. They said a ship that turns is a ship that is going somewhere, and that two hundred years of straight line had gone nowhere but the dark. "If it knows where to go," a girl shouted from a balcony, "let it."
On the other side were the Old Line. Older. Quieter. Scared in a different way. They had been born into a world with a heading, and they believed in the heading as they believed in the floor. "The founders chose the line," said a man with a pale beard. "What is a turn but a mistake nobody has had the courage to fix?"
Both sides, Ilse noticed, were afraid. They only looked at it from different angles.
"What do you think, lamplighter?"
She looked up. A boy of about fifteen was staring at her, with the hungry honest look of someone who wanted an adult to tell him what to be.
"I think," she said carefully, "that nobody here knows yet."
"That's not an answer."
"No." She had been told that twice in a day. "But it's true."
She found Tobe on the ladder by the district hall, watching the crowd as if it were a stain spreading on a map.
"Three hundred," he said. "Maybe four. Already."
"You said four thousand wouldn't be able to bear it."
"I said they'd rather not. That's different. They're bearing it. They're just picking sides to do it." He rubbed his eyes under his glasses. "It's what the Chair wanted to avoid. And it's happening anyway, because someone else decided the Council couldn't be trusted to say."
"The Chair would say she was right."
"Yes." He sounded very tired. "I'm afraid that's the worst of it. She might be."
A shout went up. A third lamp, in Ring Three, on the far side of the world, had winked out in the middle of the afternoon. The crowd turned toward it as one animal. Even from here, Ilse could hear the sound go through them, half a gasp and half a moan.
Three, she thought.
She thought of the second lamp, which the Witness had not put out. Maybe the ship, doing it by itself. Slowly, one spindle at a time, as if it were learning how.
"Tobe," she said quietly. "We have to ask the glass more questions."
"Yes."
"Real ones. And this time we don't let it slide."
He nodded. He did not look at her. And she saw, again, that small flinch at the corner of his mouth, the one that always came when she said glass.
Tonight, she decided, she would ask him about that too.