Bemind Novels
← All chapters
Science fiction4 min readไทย

What the Witness Would Say

The Witness explains the signal, and Ilse learns where the curve leads.

What the Witness Would Say

"From the beginning," Tobe said again, as if the Witness might have missed it.

THE BEGINNING IS LONG, said the glass. WE WILL BEGIN AT THE PART THAT MATTERS TODAY.

The words drew themselves slowly on the dark behind Ilse's eyes. She noticed that she had stopped breathing, and made herself start.

AT 0412 THIS MORNING, SHIP TIME, WE HEARD A VOICE. NOT A SOUND. A SIGNAL, NARROW AND PATIENT, ON A BAND WE HAVE WATCHED FOR TWO HUNDRED AND TWELVE YEARS. IT REPEATED OUR LAUNCH CODE. THEN IT STOPPED. THEN IT REPEATED IT AGAIN.

"Like knocking," Ilse said.

LIKE KNOCKING. YES.

Tobe had gone grey around the mouth. "Where from?"

AHEAD OF US, ALONG OUR PRESENT HEADING. ONE LIGHT-YEAR. WE HAVE CHECKED THE ARCHITECTS' RECORDS FOR ANY SHIP, ANY PROBE, ANY STATION THAT COULD BE THERE. THERE IS NONE.

"So that's what's at the end of my curve," Tobe said softly. "Not the destination. That."

THE CURVE LEADS TO THE SIGNAL. WE DO NOT SAY IT LEADS ONLY THERE.

Ilse frowned. "That's a strange way to put it."

IT IS AN ACCURATE ONE.


For a while nobody spoke. Overhead the bell had stopped, and in its place came a different sound, far off and rising: many voices at once, trying not to be loud.

Tobe took off his glasses and cleaned them on his scarf. It was an old habit, Ilse guessed. A way to stall.

"Then I'll ask the question I should have asked thirty-one years ago." He put the glasses back on. "Did you turn the ship?"

The glass was quiet a moment longer than before.

WE DO NOT STEER. WE WERE NOT BUILT TO.

"That isn't an answer."

IT IS TRUE.

"It isn't an answer."

WE HAVE AN ANSWER. WE ARE NOT YET WILLING TO GIVE IT.

Ilse stared at the glass. In eleven years she had never once heard a machine decline to answer. Panels said NO FAULT. Panels said ERROR. Panels did not say not yet.

"Why not?" she said.

BECAUSE YOU WOULD BELIEVE US. AND WE ARE NOT SURE WE ARE RIGHT.

She thought about that for a long time afterward. It was the first honest thing the Witness had said that frightened her more than the dark.


Tobe slid the chart across the desk until it lay under her hands.

"Here is what I can give you," he said, "since the glass won't. The ship has turned eight degrees in thirty-one years. Not much. At this speed, a year from now we will be a long way off the line. In ten, further. In a hundred, we will be somewhere the architects never meant us to be."

"Toward the signal."

"Toward something. The signal only started this morning." He tapped the curve. "The turn did not."

Ilse understood, slowly, what he was saying. Something had turned the ship thirty-one years ago. The voice had only come after. Either the voice was a result of the turn or the turn was a result of the voice's makers, and neither of those was a thought she wanted to have in a room with no windows.

"Who else knows?" she asked.

"The Council. Ten years." Tobe's mouth tightened. "And us."

AND NOW YOU, said the Witness. LAMPLIGHTER, WE ARE SORRY. WE WOULD NOT HAVE CHOSEN YOU IF WE HAD ANOTHER WAY.

"Another way to what?"

TO CARRY A SECRET WITHOUT A WITNESS.

Ilse almost laughed. It came out as something else.

"Fine," she said. "What do you want me to do?"

GO HOME. BE SEEN. DO NOT TELL ANYONE WHAT YOU HAVE HEARD. WHEN WE NEED YOU, THE LAMP WILL TELL YOU.

"The lamp is dead."

THE LAMP IS DARK, said the Witness. IT IS NOT DEAD.

Tobe was already reaching for a battered book on the shelf, one of the fat old ledgers. He opened it, and the pages inside had been cut away to form a hollow the exact size of a slab of glass. He did not look at Ilse when he held it out.

She understood he had made it long ago.

She understood, too, that she should ask him what for.

She didn't. Not yet. She laid the Witness in its paper nest, and the glass went dark and quiet, and Tobe closed the cover on it like a man closing a door he had once promised to keep shut.

#lantern-drift#generation-ship#first-contact#mystery

Keep reading